Shoulda known it would feel like this
Shoulda known how you'd fix your hair
Shoulda known that you'd do your best to remind me what I miss
Shoulda known that you wouldn't fight fair

And oh
Yeah, I planned out how this moment would go
Girl, I swear

I thought I thought this through
That I knew what I'd do
Then I saw you walk into this bar with someone new
And I thought I that I could act
Like I don't want us back
Turns out that after all this time it's still too soon
I thought I thought this through

Didn't think it would all rush back
Didn't think you'd be here alone
Didn't think I would hate that you ain't the one paying my tab
Didn't think this is how it would go

I thought I thought this through
That I knew what I'd do
Then I saw you walk into this bar with someone new
And I thought I that I could act
Like I don't want us back
Turns out that after all this time it's still too soon
I thought I thought this through

I thought I thought this through
Now I don't know what to do
'Cause I think that I just might still be in love with you

I thought I thought this through
That I knew what I'd do
Then I saw you walk into this bar with someone new
And I thought I that I could act
Like I don't want us back
Turns out that after all this time it's still too soon
I thought I thought this through