The first time
I saw you I was fifteen
Felt just like a daydream
I couldn't move
You saw me
Looking on what's holy
Got me feeling lonely
I needed you

And I still remember how I couldn't speak
And I still remember how my knees got weak
And I still remember how you smiled at me
From the cover of a magazine

... from the cover of a...
... from the cover of a magazine

Fast forward
Now those days are long gone
That was just an old song
'Bout me and you
Time flies
Baby, now I'm twenty-five
You still make me feel like
I used to do

And I still remember how I couldn't speak
And I still remember how my knees got weak
And I still remember how you smiled at me
From the cover of a magazine

... from the cover of a magazine

I gotta pinch my arm to check if this is real
You're laying right beside me and I can't believe
And I tell you, right the first time you smiled at me
From the cover of a magazine

... from the cover of a magazine
... from the cover of a magazine
... from the cover of a magazine